ON-AIR

Call or text: 0491 65 68 60

To listen, click the play triangle button above.

 

The Court of Public Opinion
Audio Live Stream HERE

9am-Midday (ACST)
Every Friday

From Roman Emperors to the White House: Carolyn Strange on the Power to Take a Life

From Roman Emperors to the White House: Carolyn Strange on the Power to Take a Life

Jeremy Cordeaux first heard Emeritus Professor Carolyn Strange in another interview and decided he wanted her on the show. On this week’s Court of Public Opinion, the ANU historian joined him to unpack the planned, and now cancelled, live stream of a US military execution by firing squad.

Studying Choices, Not Only Deaths

Professor Strange rejected the idea that executions are her passion. Her field, she said, is the history of how governments assert authority and where capital punishment fits into that story. She said the subject is as much about decisions to spare a life as decisions to end one.

She also politely sidestepped Jeremy’s question about whether the death penalty should exist, saying a historian’s opinion on that is no more valuable than anyone else’s. What she could offer, she said, was the history of its politics.

The Oldest Form of Power

According to Professor Strange, there is no more dramatic use of state power than deliberately ending someone’s life, and for most of history that power belonged to rulers. She pointed to Roman emperors signalling life or death with a thumb, and to monarchs who held the prerogative of mercy, which they used selectively.

Jeremy asked whether there is a modern equivalent. Professor Strange said there is: executive power, which in the United States lies with the president, who can authorise or commute a death sentence, as can state governors.

One Week, Two Announcements

Because this case falls under US military law, Professor Strange said, the president is the one deciding whether and how the sentence is carried out. She said he first announced a live-streamed firing squad, then a week later dropped the live stream while saying the execution would still go ahead.

She predicted the execution is very likely to face legal challenges.

Life Behind Bars Instead

Jeremy relayed a view put earlier in the show by Professor Ian Plimer, that locking the man away for the rest of his life might be the more painful punishment. Professor Strange called it a very interesting point. She said life imprisonment has generally been the substitute for the death penalty, that the president does have the authority to choose it, and that the condemned man is paralysed from the chest down.

Listen To The Full Interview

Catch the complete interview from The Court of Public Opinion, recorded live around the dining room table.

Listen To The Full Show

Listen to the full live stream of The Court of Public Opinion from Friday 16 October 2026 here.

The Court of Public Opinion streams live every Friday from 9 a.m. to 12 p.m. (ACST), right here at jeremycordeaux.com. Download the podcast anytime on your favourite podcast app, and join the conversation with your calls and comments.

Subscribe and review on your favourite podcast app

Related Articles